As a professional in dog training here in Melbourne, one of the most common questions I hear is: “Why can’t I let my dog say hello to other dogs when we’re out walking?” It seems like a friendly gesture, especially when both dogs appear interested. However, there are several important reasons why allowing on-lead greetings can create more problems than benefits. 
Firstly, dogs behave very differently when they’re on lead. A lead restricts natural body language and movement, making dogs feel tense or trapped. Even a typically calm and well-socialised dog can become reactive when their freedom is limited. I’ve seen many cases where a well-intentioned “hello” quickly turned into a growl or snap, simply because the dogs couldn’t move away from each other.
From a dog training perspective, encouraging on-lead greetings can reinforce unhealthy habits. Dogs may begin to associate every oncoming dog with the expectation of an interaction. This can lead to excessive pulling, barking, or frustration when they’re not allowed to say hello. Over time, this behaviour becomes ingrained and difficult to redirect.
I used to let my own dog greet others on lead, thinking I was being polite or social. But I noticed she started to pull towards every dog she saw, becoming increasingly difficult to walk calmly. That’s when I realised how important structured training is, especially in busy areas like Melbourne where dog parks and walking paths are full of distractions.
Another issue is that not all dogs are friendly or healthy. Some may be fearful, reactive, or even recovering from surgery. Just because your dog is social doesn’t mean the other one is. Allowing an on-lead greeting without permission can put both dogs at risk. As someone who offers dog training near me services in Melbourne, I always remind owners to avoid these interactions altogether.
Focus on using your walks as training opportunities. Practise loose lead walking, obedience cues, and engagement with you as the handler. This not only builds a stronger bond but also reinforces calm and predictable behaviour in a variety of settings.
I’ve found that when I stop allowing random on-lead greetings, my dog becomes more focused and relaxed. Walks are no longer chaotic or unpredictable – they’re enjoyable for both of us. And I get to reinforce the behaviours I want to see long-term.
Melbourne is full of great places for off-lead play and socialisation, such as designated dog parks where dogs can interact more naturally. But on a lead, your best bet is to keep moving, keep a respectful distance, and protect your dog’s space.
In dog training, we often say: just because they can, doesn’t mean they should. This applies perfectly to on-lead greetings. Be your dog’s advocate, prioritise their safety and well-being, and always train with intention.
If you’re unsure how to manage on-lead greetings or feel your dog is becoming reactive, working with a professional can make a world of difference. I often recommend searching for dog training near me to find qualified local trainers who can guide you and your dog through positive socialisation techniques. If you’re based in Melbourne, I’d love to help you build calm, confident behaviour on walks.
Check out our dog behaviour and training services for professional help tailored to you and your dog. Or call 0403 433 99 to contact Emilia.
Written by Emilia Borkowski
16.06.25
Images credited to:
Artem Beliaikin, Bundo Kim and Haberdoedas